Bar Fly Safety Harbor Menu
64 items in 9 sections · $3.00 – $26.50 · Bar & Grill in Safety Harbor, FL
Bar Fly Safety Harbor’s menu lists 64 dishes and drinks, grouped into TACOS, QUESADILLAS, WRAPS, SIDES, HANDHELDS, and Premium sides and more. Prices range from $3.00 to $26.50, and a typical item costs about $16.75. Popular choices include BAR FLY O.G. TACOS (Mahi), CHEESE, CARIBBEAN CRACKED LOBSTER WRAP, Old bay kettle chips, and CHEESEBURGER IN PARADISE.
TACOS 9
- BAR FLY O.G. TACOS (Mahi)$18.00
Our original tacos! (2) tacos w/ shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese, pineapple salsa, Bimini sauce
- BAR FLY O.G. TACOS (Shrimp)$17.00
Our original tacos! (2) tacos w/ shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese, pineapple salsa, Bimini sauce
- G-LIME GROUPER TACOS$19.00
(2) tacos w/ blackened grouper, shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese, pico, cilantro lime aioli
- LOBSTER TACOS$22.50
(2) tacos w/ lobster meat, shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese, pico, cilantro lime aioli
- TUNA TACOS$18.00
Sesame seared tuna or tuna poke' (2) tacos w/ tuna, shredded mixed cabbage, wakame, teriyaki, cucumber wasabi sauce & crunchy wontons
- ISLAND FIRE SHRIMP TACOS$17.50
(2) tacos w/ fried shrimp tossed in island fire sauce, shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese & scallions
- MANGO HABANERO SHRIMP TACOS$17.50
(2) tacos w/ fried shrimp tossed in mango habanero sauce, shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese & diced mango
- SOUTHWEST CHICKEN TACOS$14.50
(2) tacos w/ chicken, shredded lettuce, mixed cheese, pico, southwest sauce, & tortilla strips
- STEAK TACOS$18.00
Grilled steak, pico, avocado, cotija cheese, lime, crema & cilantro
QUESADILLAS 5
- CHEESE$10.00
Flour tortilla stuffed w/ mixed cheese & pico Served w/ a side of lettuce, jalapeños, pico & sour cream
- GRILLED CHICKEN$13.75
Flour tortilla stuffed w/ mixed cheese & pico Served w/ a side of lettuce, jalapeños, pico & sour cream
- BLACKENED SHRIMP$15.75
Flour tortilla stuffed w/ mixed cheese & pico Served w/ a side of lettuce, jalapeños, pico & sour cream
- LOBSTER$19.50
Flour tortilla stuffed w/ mixed cheese & pico Served w/ a side of lettuce, jalapeños, pico & sour cream
- STEAK$16.50
Flour tortilla stuffed w/ mixed cheese & pico Served w/ a side of lettuce, jalapeños, pico & sour cream
WRAPS 4
- CARIBBEAN CRACKED LOBSTER WRAP$22.00
Caribbean lobster tail bites deep fried, mixed cheese, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, onion & spicy island aioli wrapped in a flour tortilla
- ISLAND FIRE SHRIMP WRAP$17.50
Lightly battered fried shrimp tossed in island fire sauce, mixed cheese, scallions, shredded mixed cabbage wrapped in a flour tortilla
- ISLAND MAHI WRAP$19.00
Blackened mahi, plantains, mixed cabbage, red onion, diced tomatoes & spicy island aioli wrapped in a flour tortilla
- SWEET HABANERO CHICKEN WRAP$16.00
Grilled or fried chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, mixed cheese & sweet habanero & southwest sauce wrapped in a flour tortilla
SIDES 8
- Old bay kettle chips$3.00
- Tortilla chips$3.00
- Black beans & rice$4.00
- Mini corn on the cob w/ garlic butter$4.00
- Island slaw$4.00
- Fries$4.50
- Tots$4.50
- Gouda grits$4.00
HANDHELDS 13
- CHEESEBURGER IN PARADISE$16.00
1/2lb ground beef burger w/ cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, & pickles on a brioche bun
- BAR FLY SMASH BURGER$16.00
(2) smashed ground beef burger patties, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle & signature sauce
- BAR FLY CUBAN$16.00
Spanish pork, ham, salami, Swiss cheese, pickles pressed on Cuban bread w/ a side of spicy mustard
- BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH$16.50
Fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce topped w/ lettuce, tomato, blue cheese crumbles on a brioche bun
- CHICKEN CLUB SANDWICH$16.75
Grilled, blackened, or fried chicken breast, Colby jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickle on a brioche bun. Served w/ a side of avocado ranch
- PO BOYS (Shrimp)$18.50
Fried shrimp or fried grouper bites, lettuce, tomato, pickles & Bimini sauce. Served on a toasted hoagie roll
- PO BOYS (Grouper)$20.00
Fried shrimp or fried grouper bites, lettuce, tomato, pickles & Bimini sauce. Served on a toasted hoagie roll
- LOBSTER GRILLED CHEESE$26.50
Steamed cold water lobster meat, melted cheddar & colby jack cheese grilled on Texas toast. Served w/ a side of lobster bisque & old bay kettle chips
- LOBSTER ROLL$25.00
Steamed cold water lobster meat on a toasted New England roll served w/ melted butter or get it 'chill' mixed with mayo, celery & lemon on a New England roll Hot or Chill
- LOBSTER SLIDERS (2)$26.00
Steamed cold water lobster meat chilled w/ mayo, celery & lemon on toasted slider rolls Served w/ a side of lobster bisque & old bay kettle chips
- OFF THE HOOK GROUPER SANDWICH
Fresh grouper sandwich grilled, blackened or fried topped w/ lettuce, tomato, & Bimini sauce on a brioche bun
- MAHI SANDWICH$19.75
Grilled mahi, colby jack cheese, lettuce, tomato & Bimini sauce on a brioche bun
- ISLAND FISH REUBEN$22.00
Swiss cheese, island coleslaw, Bimini sauce on Texas toast Choose from grouper or Mahi
Premium sides 7
- Mini side salad$4.75
- Plantains$4.75
- Onion rings$4.75
- Chef veggies$4.75
- Hush puppies$4.75
- Sweet potato waffle fries$4.75
- Sidewinder fries$4.75
Buckets 2
- CRAB LEG BUCKET
2lbs snow crab legs steamed w/ old bay seasoning & mini corn on the cob
- BAR FLY BAIT BUCKET
1 snow crab leg cluster, 1/4lb of peel & eat shrimp, & 6 clams steamed w/ old bay seasoning, andouille sausage & mini corn on the cob
BIG BITES & baskets 6
- CATCH OF THE DAY DINNER
Fresh catch grilled, blackened or fried Served w/ coconut rice, pineapple salsa, & Chef veggies! (No substitutions)
- FRIED GROUPER BASKET$22.00
Fresh grouper nuggets fried in our house made beer batter. Served with fries & island coleslaw & a side of cilantro lime aioli or cocktail sauce
- FRIED SHRIMP BASKET$20.50
Lightly battered fried shrimp served w/ fries & island coleslaw & a side of cocktail or tartar sauce
- FRIED COCONUT SHRIMP BASKET$20.50
Fried coconut shrimp served w/ fries & island coleslaw & a tropical dipping sauce
- SHRIMP N' GRITS$18.00
Blackened shrimp, gouda grits, andouille sausage, tomatoes, bacon, & topped w/ fresh scallions
- JAMBALAYA$19.50
Spicy!...a New Orleans favorite! A heaping bowl of cajun seasoned rice topped off w/ blackened shrimp, andouille sausage, red & yellow peppers & fresh scallions, Served w/ a side of baguette bread!
Bowls 10
- BAR FLY BOWL (Mahi)$17.00
Mahi or shrimp, shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese, pineapple salsa, served over black beans & yellow rice topped w/ Bimini sauce
- BAR FLY BOWL (shrimp)$16.00
Mahi or shrimp, shredded mixed cabbage, mixed cheese, pineapple salsa, served over black beans & yellow rice topped w/ Bimini sauce
- COCONUT SHRIMP BOWL$16.50
Fried coconut shrimp, mixed cheese, shredded mixed cabbage, pineapple salsa served over black beans & yellow rice topped w/ sweet habanero sauce
- SOUTHWEST CHICKEN BOWL$15.00
Grilled chicken, mixed cheese, shredded lettuce, pico, fire roasted corn & pepper blend served over black beans & yellow rice & topped w/ tortilla strips & southwest sauce
- STREET CORN SALMON BOWL$19.00
Grilled seasoned salmon w/ an elote seasoned blend, fire roasted corn & peppers, Pico de gallo, fresh cilantro, cotija cheese & avocado ranch served over black beans & yellow rice
- TROPICAL ISLAND BOWL$14.00
Mixed cabbage, mango, avocado, plantains, carrot & radish mix. Served over black beans & cilantro lime coconut rice w/ sweet chili sauce
- TROPICAL ISLAND BOWL w/grilled chicken$16.00
Mixed cabbage, mango, avocado, plantains, carrot & radish mix. Served over black beans & cilantro lime coconut rice w/ sweet chili sauce
- TROPICAL ISLAND BOWL w/grilled shrimp$17.00
Mixed cabbage, mango, avocado, plantains, carrot & radish mix. Served over black beans & cilantro lime coconut rice w/ sweet chili sauce
- TROPICAL ISLAND BOWL w/grilled salmon$19.00
Mixed cabbage, mango, avocado, plantains, carrot & radish mix. Served over black beans & cilantro lime coconut rice w/ sweet chili sauce
- ISLAND TUNA POKE BOWL$20.00
Sushi grade tuna (raw) tossed in teriyaki poke & sweet chili sauce served w/ coconut rice, mixed greens, avocado, cucumber,carrot & radish mix, wakame, & shelled edamame. Topped w/ scallions, sesame seeds, a drizzle of cucumber wasabi & ter
How these prices compare
Based on 17 menus with 691 priced items from bars & grills in Florida, the median menu item costs $11.50, and half of all items are priced between $7.00 and $16.00.
At Bar Fly Safety Harbor the median listed price is $16.75, higher than the typical $11.50 for bars & grills in Florida.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Onion Rings | $4.75 | $4.88 |
Typical prices are calculated from 17 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.